Its probably only a matter of time before he becomes fully infatuated, which would easily allow Sarah to take over as a puppeteer for his legal wrangling talents. Whatever it was, shes probably not thinking much straighter now, and while it may be an ill-advised move to press charges against any Duttons without a monolithic corporation behind her, its still the only logical one. Anyone entering John Duttons inner circle needs around 15 rounds of vetting, but she came out of nowhere as far as viewers are concerned, and is working with John out of duty, as opposed to out of loyalty. in this quasi-relationship, with Dawn Olivieris character wholeheartedly appealing to his sexual desires in place of his law-degree logic. As the oldest Dutton son, Lee managed the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch and was expected to take over the ranch from John. Hell, it might not be unintentional at all, given how betrayed he feels, but hell no doubt believe that itll all work out in his favor. The bonds of their marriage have been stretched beyond their limits, only to reform again around the fissure. Who Were Ned and Chance Dutton? Fans who have re-watched the show (or had a rather thorough first watch) may remember hearing of Chance and Ned Dutton. The people who stayed on the ranch because they didnt have families to fall back on, and who owe much of their lives to John and the brand? Good Housekeeping participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites. Im honestly not sure what the implications would be if 1883s protagonist was the genuine John Dutton Sr., and what that would mean for James Badge Dales John in the upcoming prequel 1923. It is likely that series co-creator Taylor Sheridan had not crafted the Dutton familys backstory while the first episode was filmed, explaining the lack of explanation about the graves of the two forgotten Duttons. Early episodes of Yellowstone show tombstones for Ned and Chance Dutton, who both lived in the mid to late 19th century. As part of Taste of Country's comprehensive coverage of all things Yellowstone, check out our Dutton Rules podcast on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. No deaths during the second episode of the night could have stacked up emotionally to the devastating loss that Kayce and Monica went through, but it stands to reason that the calves and wolves that were killed could have more far-reaching ramifications on the whole. Please refresh the page and try again. Ned's headstone says 3/16/1863 so if he is buried there, he died after 1886 according to John's speech at the Stockman's Dinner. Given what we already know of Beths traumatizing teen years, is it possible that Yellowstone will give Rowdy a twist thats anywhere near as shocking? If you are wondering why the Duttons are buried on their ranch in Yellowstone, here is everything you need to know! Appearances Season 1 Daybreak (episode 1) - Mentioned References Season 1, episode 1: Daybreak Others like you also viewed Which likely means Jamie will continue to walk along the edge with his latest lapse in professional judgment, she who calls herself Sarah Atwood. The Dutton family has been buried at the Yellowstone for over a century. During Lees funeral in season one, we are given glimpses of Ned and Chance Duttons gravestones, and John takes time to remember Ned during the service. Tall Drink of Water tested that specific hypothesis in certain ways, with several of the main characters making truly questionable choices that, appropriately enough, felt far more scripted for TV than authentic actions these people would be making. Plus, why would John think of headstones of long deceased ancestors when he was burying Lee, his son? Did 'Grey's Anatomy' Set Up Ellen Pompeo's Return? Before knowing Jamie was adopted, I had a suspicion for some time that Lee was not John 3s son, but instead a son Chance or Neds son. At this point, Im 100% wondering if Faith Hills Margaret Dutton will be featured once more in another prequel season that explores her life as a widow, with or without her children in her stead. Just to get it straight right from the start: there is only ONE Beth Dutton, and there will only ever be one Beth Dutton. Tough as nails, resolute,. The third episode of 1923 (and simple math) makes it clear these men are not the same man. From fleeing a life of poverty to owning the largest cattle ranch in Montana, the family has come a long way. Another fan pointed out that the photos shown appear to have some greater significance, which means there may be more to Lee's absence than meets the eye. Perhaps this is one of the show's best-kept secrets and we'll learn more in the episodes to come. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Theories. John Dutton, played by Kevin Costner, is the patriarch of a ranching family and owner of the largest ranch in the U.S. Dutton's Yellowstone Ranch borders the national park of the same name, a. But no, theres just a little too much going on behind her eyes to squash all suspicions outright. Characters Lee Dutton is a ranch hand of the Yellowstone Ranch and the oldest son of ranch owner John Dutton and his wife Evelyn Dutton. Anytime Jamie Dutton thinks hes the most important mover and shaker in the room, Yellowstone fans know hes probably wrong, but its at least a change of pace from the defeated servant vibe he has anytime Beth is around. But at the least, theres a chance we may learn more about Chance and Ned, the forgotten Duttons, in future episodes of either Yellowstone or 1883. 6 Big Yellowstone Questions After Episode 505 And Beth's Latest Bloody Fight, Yellowstone: My Biggest Worries After Episode 504, Including That Beth And Jamie Reveal, Yellowstones Worst Character Decisions From Episode 503, Including Beths Violent Night Out, Yellowstone's Most Important Takeaways From Season 5's Double-Ep Premiere, Including That Tragic Death, Ahead Of Renfield, Nicolas Cage Makes Case For His Dracula To Get A Solo Movie, Yellowstones Piper Perabo And Lainey Wilson Shared Thoughts On Those Wild Kevin Costner Rumors, James Gunn Explains Why He's Now Making A Superman Movie After Previously Turning Down The Opportunity, Star Trek: Discovery Is Ending With Season 5 On Paramount+, But There Is Good News, Disneyland Had A Classic Reaction As Fans Shared Posts Of It Snowing In The California Parks This Week. The Duttons make their entrance in Yellowstone's pilot as well, full of the convoluted, painful, and potent ties the show goes on to explore at length. So lets lace up our gloves and step into the ring that is the Duttons front yard. He's a young man who helped his father and great-uncle (Jacob Dutton) on their relatively new land. 20 Best Modern Western TV Shows for Cowboy Lovers, You Can Spend the Night at the Iconic Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, James sister Claire before she shot herself she said she had lost all 7 of her children His brother Jacob and his wife Cars had no children YELLOWSTONE season 4 is just around the corner and fans are still waiting to find out who ordered the attacks on the Dutton family. Beth might think shes in one of Taylor Sheridans prequels, where busting up other peoples faces is as much a way of life as living by the law, but thats obviously not the case here. Most of Yellowstones characters experience narrative ebbs and flows, but Kayce and Monica are often tied up in dark and emotionally devastating stories. Only Taylor Sheridan knows for sure. Gender Jacki Weavers Caroline Warner speaks of Sarah as if she herself is the code to the nuclear football, which makes a certain amount of sense if she wields similar fuck the world energy to that which Beth emanates at solar levels. Up until then she's only described as Margaret Dutton's (Faith Hill) sister-in-law, but since her last name is Dutton, she must be kin to James and Jacob. Our readers support us. There was a problem. It also reveals Peter Dutton as John Dutton's (Costner) brother, a boy who died as a baby (revealed during Season 5 of Yellowstone). Thanks to Rubys sleuthing, however, we do know that at least Ned Dutton wouldve been a contemporary of 1883s John Dutton Sr., played by tiny Audie Rick for that series (in the Yellowstone Season 4 flashback, hes played by another, older actor). Yellowstone continues to represent a citizens-before-government attitude, and it would be bonkers if life imitated art in just such a way, at least when it comes to elements that are truly expendable. But considering their conversation largely revolves around John Dutton as an entity, could just as easily have been implying he was the first in the family to don that name. As amusing as it is to think about Jamie as a happy-go-lucky suburban dad, his feelings in this situation arent anywhere near as important as what happens with his son, who is easily the only innocent Dutton left. On the one (bruised and beer-dampened) hand, it was as clear as the day is long that Beth wasnt going to let any other woman get away with anything so iniquitous as smiling while talking to Rip. When Beths in a good mood, she likes to fuck and fight, and the Bozeman bar was just a little too populated for the former. Biographical information Based on the information from Yellowstone, 1883 and 1923, we can break down the Dutton family tree into seven generations. Maybe just one week? I have the same theory that they could possibly be other children, but it never revisits these graves. FYI: Evelyn's cross-shaped headstone reads "Evelyn Dutton Met God Here March 30, 1997". Subscribe to our newsletter for new stories, tips & events. His love for his wife and daughters is almost equaled by his love of gasp-for-breath laughter and gasp-for-breath horror. Therefore, several members of the family are buried on the land. John said "Since 1886, every Dutton who died is buried 300 yards from my back porch. Others theorize that Ned and Chance could have been nephews to James who traveled to the ranch after it was established. Like the dialogue noted above, this line could be taken two different ways. But the Market Equities headhunter has already penetrated the family more quickly than Caroline Warner and others, so its logical to be concerned that her lack of familial ties in this situation gives her an advantage. Also expectedly, Rip wasnt exactly a gentleman during that exchange. by Sophie Cook March 3, 2023, 4:03 pm. Even with the arrival of 1883, there's a whole lot more we don't know than has been confirmed. I just rechecked Lee's funeral scene to look at the headstones frame-by-frame, but I could not see the date on Chance's because the prairie grass obscured it. Edit/Wild Theory Addition: It is possible the semi-obscured date on Ned's was 1(9)86. If the second John Sr. (Coleman) were Spencer's boy, that would wipe out a full generation and only make Costner's John a fourth-generation rancher. Just super random. They make it a point to see it," the fan wrote. Early episodes of Yellowstone show tombstones for Ned and Chance Dutton, who both lived in the mid to late 19th century. However, they are present in spirit during the series premiere episode. Yellowstone, 1883 and 1923 fans will appreciate this easy explanation of how James, Jacob and John Dutton are related. Yellowstone gave viewers an impromptu throwdown that mirrored Season 4s last man standing brawl between Lloyd and Walker. Early episodes of Yellowstone show tombstones for Ned and Chance Dutton, who both lived in the mid to late 19th century. Like, I can get someone on the outer perimeter like Gator having a personal life away from the ranch, even if hes spending sooo much time cooking for the Duttons and various guests. Surdo in Provincia di Cosenza (Calabria) with it's 1,659 citizens is a city in Italy about 262 mi (or 422 km) south-east of Rome, the country's capital city. Because we all know that when Beth puts the effort into her deeds, schemes, and exploits, she succeeds in ways that justify vodka at dawn (vaguely), but its when she follows her instincts against better judgment that she legitimately threatens herself and those around her. How would we know? It was founded by James Dutton, a Tennessee farmer who relocated with his family from Fort Worth, Texas to Montana during the Western Expansion, while the caravan was making the trek to Oregon. In Yellowstone, John Dutton proclaims that generations of Duttons have found their final resting place at their ranch. However, John Dutton III from Yellowstone never talks about a lost or deceased brother. Meanwhile, James daughter, Elsa Dutton, is gravely injured and near death. Taylor Sheridan's creation has expanded to include the Dutton family origin story with 1883 and 1923, and with new installments (1883: The Bass Reeves Story and 6666) on the horizon, we don't expect the world to be simplified any time soon. James Dutton (Tim McGraw), the lead of 1883 is John. But any attempts to feel joy about such miracles were clearly destined for doom as soon as Monica confidently declared she would drive herself to the hospital. New York, Where her main motivation should be to keep out of any trouble that could draw negative attention to Johns atypical maneuvers as Montanas governor, her actual mission statement appears to be Gotcha, bitch. She couldnt just let sleeping (with her father) dogs lie by giving Summer her space, not that Piper Perabos homebound activist made her face any less punchable by railing on Gators dinner spread. Let's break it down. Chance and Ned are among them; two Duttons we dont know enough about to firmly place on a family tree. [1] Chance's birth date and the date of his death are unknown. We obviously know that the Duttons keep their nearest and dearest family members close to home after theyve passed, but what about the many hands who have joined the bleedin bunkhouse invisible? This brought fans to the conclusion that these names must hold some significance within the family. Nick is a Cajun Country native, and is often asked why he doesn't sound like that's the case. However, with very little information besides their names, fans have been asking questions regarding these two mysterious Duttons. But wait, were already getting down to the brass tacks before Ive even had a proper shot at setting anything up, which is pretty much what Beth did when she first clocked Summers naively unaware face. If Lilli Kay wasnt such a consistent presence on Yellowstone, it might be easy to lounge back without making assumptions about the character Clara. Even if the trip itself doesnt skew too harrowing for anyone, the return to the ranch may be where things go south, especially with Johns plans to go mega-public in showing the outside world how the Duttons live. Also, many speculate that Chance Dutton is either another of James Duttons nephews, or the brother of John Dutton III. We've marked that as speculation since it's not been confirmed. Nah, that shits been coming for a long time, and I am so ready to start hollering at my TV when it happens, hopefully as Season 5 heads into its winter hiatus, giving way to Paramount+'s upcoming prequel 1923. So what does that mean? Fans met days of Dutton past first with Yellowstone prequel 1883, and now we're being introduced to the next lineage in the latest installment of the story: 1923.The tale of Cara and Jacob . John continued to make it clear where he stands on Jamies place within the family by referring to him as the child he regrets, and not counting him amongst his sons. During the funeral of Lee Dutton, two graves are seen in the background. During Season 5 we also see a headstone for Patience Dutton, who lived in the early 20th century. My theory at the time was that Chance/ Ned suffered a similar death to Lee and it was going to be a plot point in S1. Chance and Ned are the Dutton family, and the viewers couldn't wait to know more about them. Those who watched 1883 remember a Crow elder telling McGraw's James Dutton that he could have the land he was sent to to bury his daughter, but in seven generations, the tribe would take it back.